Title: Asurya Lokas Author: Martin Ross Type: Humorous casefile; Valentine's Day theme Rating: PG-13 for adult language and innuendo Synopsis: Mulder and Scully investigate a strange case of murder and animal attraction – and repulsion. Spoilers: None Disclaimer: The X-Files is the property of 10-13 Productions, Chris Carter, and Fox. "The only problem with your murder theory," Scully suggested as she scanned the now-waxy body on the exam table, "is that no one was murdered." "Not in the traditional sense, maybe," Mulder countered. "If by the 'traditional sense,' you mean caused to die at the hands of another, neither by accident nor the transmission of disease, then I'd be interested to know in what innovative and exotic manner you believe Mr. Rhawalpindi died. I did a complete workup, and there is no doubt whatsoever that this man was the victim of anaphylactic shock. My post- mortem turned up an insect sting, Mr. Rhawalpindi's doctor told me the victim suffered from several severe allergies, and, most compellingly, we found a dead North American honey bee near the body." "And your problem is…?" Mulder demanded as his partner re-covered the body. "In a general sense, or specifically referring to the case at hand? Which isn't a case, by the way." Pittsburgh, Pa. Three days earlier The strange and yet poignantly mundane death of Rajiv Rhawalpindi had come to the FBI's attention only because he had through several tenuous relationships and even more tenuous circumstances been deemed a "person of interest" under the Patriot Act. In the pre-911 world, the young software developer's introspective, nearly monastic lifestyle would have drawn little notice. In the post-911 world, the quiet Pakistani-American, whose sixth cousin had made some rashly nationalistic remarks at a demonstration a half-continent away, was viewed as almost too quiet. So when Rhawalpindi, the subject of ongoing FBI surveillance, had been found dead without a mark in his Washington living/dining/computer room/den, memories of anthrax and Japanese saran gas prompted a CDC/EPA crew to covertly swoop down on his two-room flat. Every scrap of correspondence, every book, every pot, pan, and prospective chemical mixing vessel was confiscated and examined with every high- tech device the FBI, the ATF, and the CIA could muster. With the exception of an ornate statue of the elephant god Ganesh that adorned a corner table and an addiction to eBay (Golden and Silver Age DC comics), the authorities could find little to justify the late Mr. Rhawalpindi's status as a person of much of any interest. However, Assistant Director Walter Skinner, no big fan of John Ashcroft or the Patriot Act but a man devoted to his duty as the law prescribed, managed to satisfy his dual sentiments by assigning both one of his best agents and one of the Bureau's most aggravated wiseasses to the Rhawalpindi investigation. Both were the same man, and Skinner knew Mulder would appreciate the absurdities of the case while exhaustively eliminating any possible of terrorist malfeasance. "Mr. Rolla--, Rawla, oh, shoot, Rajiv was a very polite young man," Mulder and Scully had learned from Olive Pizer, the decedent's possibly 130-year-old apartment super. "Every once in a while, I'd smell that incense stuff coming from under his door, and I suppose he might've smoked a little of that reefer weed the kids seem to like, but boys will be boys, won't they? I can't believe he would have anything to do with that horrible Mr. bin Laden. He always tied up his garbage bags very securely, and he never played his music loud during my CSI." Mulder pictured Osama sloppily applying a slip knot to his Hefty bag, and suppressed a smile. "How long had he been living here?" Without soliciting it, Pizer poured Mulder and Scully a second cup of a particularly acrid tea neither agent originally had invited. "Oh, my. Mr. Clinton was president…Yes, it was right after that nasty Lewinski girl was all over the news. She was my daughter, I'd have given her a good spanking." "That'd teach her. And no trouble during that time?" "As I said, he was extremely polite. Always had his rent to me first of the month. A nice boy, even if he was the unluckiest young man I ever met." Scully perked. "Unlucky how?" "Wellll, first of all, there was that girlfriend of his – oh, what was her name? This was maybe three years ago. She was one of them, too. Palestinian." "Pakistani." "Yes. They were to married – Rajiv was very happy. Then she got hit by the No. 12." "Pardon?" "Bus. The No. 12 crosstown bus. She was a student at the college, and she was going to one of her classes when the No. 12 swerved to avoid a boy on a bicycle. I understand she was killed instantly. The poor boy was heartbroken." "Not to mention the girl," Mulder suggested. "Well," Pizer murmured non-committally. "It seems as if poor Rajiv's life went downhill after that. The accident took place a few months after that girl died." "Accident?" "The oddest thing I ever heard of," the senior related. "He hit a deer in his car. At 11 p.m. on a Tuesday night, downtown. It leapt in front of his car, and he killed it." "Mrs. Pizer, would you know if any of his co-workers ever--?" Scully began hastily, hoping to divert her partner. "A deer, you say," Mulder said. "Was he hurt?" "Rajiv? Oh, no. He had one of those balloons, you know, those car balloons." "Airbag?" "That's it. Oh, no – the mauling was much worse." "Mauling?" Mulder leaned forward, a childlike gleam in his eyes. Scully sat back and sipped her industrial tea in resignation. "Yes. A poodle. Or a Pomeranian. The one with, you know, the eyes…" "A poodle mauled Mr. Rhawalpindi." "Yes. Or a Pomeranian. A stray, I believe – there was no collar. It was horrid. Rajiv was out front, getting ready to go visit his parents on the west side, when the little cur just, well, launched itself at him. It was, well, just gnawing at his neck – blood was all over the sidewalk. It took Mr. Wallace in 2 and Ms. Jankowicz in 6 to get it off him. The bitch." "Ah, the dog?" Mulder ventured carefully. "Yes, it was a female. I remember now. Even when they pried the poodle from Rajiv's throat, it tried to reattach itself. Mr. Wallace was forced to use a golf club from his trunk to beat the dog to death. A No. 7, he told me at the time, although I haven't the slightest interest in that silly game." Mulder's eyes were wide now. "Then what happened?" "Well, I suppose all of this must have taken its toll on Rajiv, because he attempted to hang himself one day. This was a few months after the mauling – for a while, he could scarcely be persuaded to leave his apartment. But that day, he'd just gotten back from a Pirates game, and he seemed very chipper, if I may say. Then I discovered a piece of Rajiv's mail had gotten in with mine, and I went up to his apartment to return it. I could hear his music, and so I knocked, but he didn't answer. I was concerned, so I unlocked his door to check on him. Rajiv was hanging from the light fixture, which certainly wasn't built to withstand that sort of weight. I called the ambulance, and they were able to bring him around." "Did he say why he did such a thing?" "When I visited the hospital, he apologized profusely for frightening me and for abusing the light fixture," Pizer informed Mulder. "He said he realized that he'd made a dreadful mistake, that his plan wouldn't have worked. Oh, he said…Yes, he said he'd realized he was too good for it to work, which seemed a little odd and uncharacteristically boastful. He promised me he would never try it again, that suicide was useless and he should get on with life. That was about four months ago, and he was fine until, of course, he died this morning. Oh, my; you don't think he killed himself?" "It's too early to determine," Scully replied, "but it would initially appear that he didn't." Mrs. Pizer shook her silver-blue head. "Poor young man. He was so unlucky." She leaned toward Mulder, and her voice took on a confidential tone. "I don't want to speak ill of the dead or judge another person's faith, but I always felt the boy worshipping Babar the Elephant would lead to no good." J. Edgar Hoover Building Three days later "All right, let's indulge your precariously teetering imagination," Scully finally piped up. She had resisted the temptation to rise to Mulder's thesis on the trip back from the Quantico pathology lab, during lunch, and throughout most of the afternoon at the office. Mulder turned, a triumphant grin on his face. "Why, Scully, what if Skinner should walk in?" His partner closed her eyes for a second. "Let us examine this so-called 'case' logically. Means, motive, and opportunity – the keystones of any homicide. I don't see any of the three here. Take opportunity: For this to be a murder, the killer would have to have known Rajiv Rhawalpindi was prone to anaphylactic allergies and ensure he would be stung by a bee in his apartment." "Absolutely. That's essential. It's key to this murder." "And what," Scully asked patiently, "was this omniscient killer's motive." Mulder pushed his chair back, rose, and came around the desk. He crooked a finger under Scully's chin and kissed her lightly. "Why, love, mon cheri," he murmured Gallicly. "You want a Diet Pepsi?" Pittsburgh, Pa. Two days earlier "He didn't get real weird until the shitzu attacked him," Byrin Gittes told the agent, fingering his eyebrow ring and eyeing his Mac like a lover he'd been forced to abandon mid-coitus. "I thought it was a poodle," Mulder said. The chief programmer of 3.0 Development shrugged. "Whatever. It like messed up Raj's mojo or something. He started gettin' all religious and all. And worse, man. I showed up at his place with a pizza one night, and he was readin' a biography of some old actress broad. The one was in that chick flick. Actually, maybe she was in a bunch of chick flicks. That was when I knew Raj was seriously whacked. Then he brought in the snake." Mulder straightened in his chair. "Snake?" "Yeah. He almost got his ass fired over that. Raj like insisted the thing had somehow gotten in through the air vent, but I think he was into, you know, that snake handling shit." "Snake handling's generally a fundamentalist Christian practice, and I understand Mr. Rhawalpindi was a devoted Hindu." "Well, snake charming, then. Though I never saw any, you know, flute or nothing." "What kind of snake was it?" "What do I look like, man? An ornithologist or something? One of the code writers freaked and beat the shit out of it. Raj almost freaked on him, which I why I think he brought it in, you know…" "To charm," Scully supplied. "Did you know Rajiv's fiancé, Sana?" "Jesus," Gittes breathed. "You mean Indira Ghastly? Sana was a world-class bitch, dude. She had Raj's cojones in a firm grip at all times, and she looked at us like we were a bunch of lowlifes or something. Especially the babes. Sorry, ma'am – the chicks. She had like a permanent she-hard-on for any chick even smiled at Raj. Don't mean to diss the dead or nothin'." "Certainly," Mulder said. ** "Terms of Endearment?" Mulder squeaked as he sorted through the personal effects the FBI Homeland Security Squad had removed from the Rhawalpindi apartment. He displayed another DVD. "Steel Magnolias? My God, The Cemetery Club? Scully, certainly you see the pattern here. It doesn't take a behavioral scientist." Scully repacked a stack of T-shirts emblazoned with catchy cyberphrases. "Pattern?" "Scully, our victim, Mr. Rhawalpindi, was a serious, serial pussy." "Ah, the professionalism," Scully sang, moving on to Rhawalpindi's books. "Seriously, though, here's this software guy who creates cyber-warriors and loves baseball and the NFL. How does this square?" "Not everyone's an aficionado of the works of Jackie Chan and the Three Stooges, Mulder," Scully offered drily. She hefted a thin volume. "Looks like Mr. Rhawalpindi was exploring his feminist side literarily, as well." Mulder stepped around the boxes, and read the binding. "The Search for Bridey Murphy. That's not beach reading, Scully. It's the true story of a woman's paranormal experiences." "A man after your own heart. Mulder, we're wasting our time here. This poor man was no terrorist – just lonely and unlucky." "Very lonely," Mulder murmured, glancing at Shirley MacLaine's smiling face on the DVD cover. J. Edgar Hoover Building Two days later "Love?" Scully challenged as Mulder set her soda on the desk. "Rajiv Rhawalpindi was murdered because of love." Mulder ripped the end from his Butterfinger wrapper. "Money, love, and in-laws. Your big three. Yes, I think love was at the root of Rhawalpindi's death. Dark, obsessive love, but love nonetheless." "And who might have loved Mr. Rhawalpindi enough to - - what was it now -- have him stung to death?" "Don't forget the car accident, the shitzu attack—" "I thought it was a Pomeranian…" "— and the snake attack." Scully popped her Pepsi and leaned back. "I've thought about that. I don't suppose you saw an item, about a week ago, about a Chicago police dog suspended for biting an African-American child only a few minutes after allowing a white boy to pet it?" "Racist dogs, Scully?" Mulder laughed. "Of course, I've read about the phenomenon. Some say it has to do with canine visual perception, others a lack of canine cross-cultural exposure. Personally, I believe sometimes shitzu just happens. That's your theory? That Rajiv Rhawalpindi was the successive victim of a racist deer, a supremacist lap dog, a religiously intolerant serpent, and a xenophobic bee?" "Any theory I might propound," Scully said evenly, "would be irrelevant, because there is no murder. I suppose next, you're going to try to tell me Rhawalpindi committed suicide via anaphylaxis." "No," Mulder stated seriously. "He'd given up on that idea. And that was probably about the last straw for the killer." Scully's brow arched. "The mysterious lover who planted a deadly bee in Rhawalpindi's apartment." "You're close." Pittsburgh, Pa. One day earlier "Like something on the goddamn Fox network," Sgt. Oz Detterich told Mulder, swabbing a French fry. "'When Freakin' Bambi Goes Bad.' Yeah, I remember it, OK – ain't every night we get a deer go berserk in the downtown area." Mulder unwrapped his Whopper With Cheese. "How do you think it got that far into the city?" The cop, mouth full of potato, shook his head. "We always kinda figured maybe somebody brought her in as a prank, or maybe some hunter hit her out in Bucks County, threw her over the hood for a trophy or for some venison sausage, and she just wasn't quite dead enough. Yeah, I know. But it makes about as much sense as anything else did. Maybe the thing was sick or something." "Did you do a post-mortem?" The cop grinned. "Nah. We had a pretty good idea what killed her." Mulder smiled back, sheepishly. "Sorry. Did you have any witnesses to the accident?" "Three or four late-night partiers who saw the doe before it ran in front of the motorist's car. They said it was just standing there, still as a statue. Couple cars came past before Mr. Rhawalpindi, and they said the thing didn't move. Only ran out into the street when Rhawalpindi drove through. Almost like she was waiting for him. Like bad karma." "You have no idea," Mulder murmured. ** "You should pardon me for saying," Singh Rhawalpindi told Mulder, "but Sana was perhaps the finest argument I ever saw for the old pre-arranged marriages of my father's and grandfather's times. She was a grasping, venal, and rabidly jealous woman." "Rabidly jealous?" Mulder echoed, regarding the graying orthodontist. Rhawalpindi brushed a piece of lint from his smock. "Agent Mulder, one of my nephews was married a few weeks prior to Sana's unfortunate death, and Rajiv brought her along. Well, at the party afterward, Sana mistook a cousinly embrace for an overture toward Rajiv, and nearly wrestled the poor woman into the buffet table. You should have seen the look of murderous rage in Sana's eyes. She was pathologically, violently possessive. She told my son that he was hers' forever." Mulder nodded thoughtfully as his cell phone sounded. He flipped it open. "Mulder." "Yeah, Agent Mulder?" a brisk voice grunted. One of the zealous domestic security guys with whom Mulder and Scully had been liaising. "Ran down that reading list you wanted." Working on a slowly emerging hypothesis, Mulder had used what he'd felt to be one of the more odious and invasive provisions of the Patriot Act to his advantage. He'd asked one of the junior Efrem Zimbalists to dig up Rhawalpindi's public library record for the past three months. Mulder scrambled for his notebook and pen. "Yeah, shoot." "We got nada," the agent reported. "Nothing. Just a bunch of religious stuff – Hindu, Muslim, some stuff about Indians. Not Rhawalpindi's kind, the woo-woo- woo kind." "Native Americans, you mean?" Mulder suggested, suppressing his irony. "Yeah," the agent grunted, missing Mulder's suppression. "Oh, and a couple books by some guy named Casey." Jackpot, Mulder thought. "Would that be C-A-Y-C-E?" "Roger that," the agent affirmed. Mulder smiled at the father of the deceased "person of interest," who frowned curiously. "Anything by George Orwell on that list?" he added mischievously. "Orwell?...Nah." "Peace out, then." J. Edgar Hoover Building One day later "Edgar Cayce," Scully perked, draining her diet soda. "The psychic." "And expert in reincarnation," Mulder added. Scully fell silent. "Mulder, I'm a little surprised you'd leap to such a cultural stereotype. Just because Rhawalpindi was a Hindu--" "As a Hindu, Rhawalpindi likely was more aware of the phenomenon of reincarnation than most Christians, Jews, or Zoroastrians would be. And actually, Scully, Hinduism doesn't have any exclusive claim to the perpetuation and migration of the soul. The Muslim Q'uran states, 'Every living being shall taste death, then unto us you will be returned.' Many American Indian tribes maintain animals and even non-living objects possess souls. I think that's why Rajiv Rhawalpindi developed his interest in chick flicks. I think it was an offshoot of his fascination for Shirley MacLaine and her fascination with reincarnation and past lives." "Shirley," Scully mouthed, "MacLaine." "What if the karma we create in this life shapes our destiny, Scully? What if the evil we do demotes us to a lower niche on the food chain in the next life? Or the good we do elevates us? I think these are the questions Rajiv Rhawalpindi began asking himself when the pattern began to emerge." "And what pattern was that, Mulder?" "Deer, dog, snake, bee. What would that succession suggest to you?" "Steps on the evolutionary ladder? Except is a deer higher up the ladder than a dog, or just larger?" "Don't quibble. I think Rajiv began to suspect that his bizarre series of animal attacks was no accident, and he started to consider the possibility that these animals were consciously attempting to kill him. But why would the animal kingdom be out to kill a single human being." Scully propped her heels on Mulder's desk. "Obviously, you've never watched America's Funniest Home Videos." "Sarcastic isn't sexy, Scully. Look at the evidence. Who would know the route through downtown Pittsburgh Rhawalpindi took when he visited his parents? Who would be in a position to know he was susceptible to anaphylactic shock? And who would have a reason to want him dead?" "Love," Scully recalled. "Love. After the accident with the deer and the shi--, ah, dog and snake attacks, I think Rhawalpindi began to wonder why Death was knocking at his apartment door. Then his cultural orientation kicked in, and he started to ponder the possibility that Sana had been reincarnated, and that he was on her hit list. "Sana was a rabidly jealous woman, as Rajiv's old man noted. She told Rajiv he belonged to her forever, and she meant it. She wanted Rajiv to join her on the next astral plane, and tried to punch his ticket to get him aboard. The problem is, like most obsessive, self-directed people, Sana never understood the nature of karma. Her transgressions as a woman earned her a zoological demotion, and her misplaced 'love' for Rajiv made her sink deeper into fanatical obsession and her attempts on her boyfriend's life. With each descent in karma, Sana got bumped down a few more species." "Reincarnation for Dummies," Scully sighed. "And I suppose Rhawalpindi's suicide attempt was some tragically romantic bid to join Sana in the afterlife." "Now, I'm getting real tingly, Scully. I think Rhawalpindi became convinced his one true – if deeply flawed – love was reaching out for him from beyond death, and he decided to join her. But dangling over his coffee table that day Mrs. Pizer discovered him, I think he had a dual revelation. No. 1, that killing yourself is neither as easy or fun as one might think. No. 2, that he and Sana were ships that were spiritually incapable of passing in the night or at any other time. Remember what he told Mrs. Pizer while he was recovering in the hospital? That his plan wouldn't work. That he was 'too good' to make it work. Rajiv Rhawalpindi was a kind, polite, considerate man. His death likely would serve merely to elevate him to a higher station, while Sana was doomed to progress further and further down the evolutionary ladder. By now, she may be a blade of grass, a virus, a telemarketer. Rajiv Rhawalpindi ultimately realized he was simply too good for her, and I think perhaps he suffered the fatal sting of a woman scorned." Mulder leaned back in his chair, waiting for Scully to jeer his theory or offer a witty bon mot. Instead, the redheaded agent rose, walked to the door, and fished into her handbag. She returned and slid a large pink envelope across his desk. Mulder stared down at the valentine, then looked up guiltily. Scully smirked. "Men. No, Mulder; don't say a word. This may surprise you – it certainly surprises me -- but I'm strangely touched by your odd and clumsy little theory. The idea of a love that transcends death, a desire manifested in such single- minded obsession, it shows me a romantic dimension that, frankly, I wouldn't have suspected of you." She moved around the desk and eased onto Mulder's lap, wrapping her arms about her partner's neck. "Yeah, you say you love me," Mulder murmured, feeling rather warm, "But would you kill me?" "Keep talking," Scully whispered.